Planning your nonprofit’s AI strategy for 2026
Looking back, 2025 was the year of AI curiosity for the nonprofit sector.
A lot of us spent it in wait-and-see mode, or in trial and error. Maybe you tried ChatGPT a few times and watched the Dreamforce announcements with a mix of excitement and skepticism. If you feel like you haven’t figured it out yet, you’re in good company. Most organizations are still near the starting line.
Reflection only helps if it leads to action, though. My hope for 2026 is that we use AI on purpose, with a plan behind it.
“Implement AI” is too vague to be a goal
When you sit down to do your planning this week, it’s tempting to add “implement AI” as a line item. That’s about as useful as adding “use a computer” to your strategy. It’s too broad to act on and too broad to measure.
It’s the same reason most New Year’s resolutions fail. “Use more AI” is a wish, and you won’t be able to tell in December whether you did it.
What I’d plan for instead are the foundations that make AI work:
- Data health. Cleaning up the silos so AI has good information to work from.
- Staff literacy. Moving past one-off prompts so AI is built into how the work actually gets done.
- Governance. The guardrails that protect your donors and your mission.
Know where you’re starting from
Before you buy another subscription or book another demo, get an honest read on where your foundations are strong and where they’re crumbling. Do it for fundraising, programs and admin separately, because most nonprofits are further along in one than the others.
That baseline does two jobs. It tells you what to fix first, and it gives you something to measure your progress against next December.
It also gets everyone on the same page. In a lot of nonprofits, AI adoption happens in pockets. One person in fundraising is a power user while the programs team is still hesitant. That leads to data silos and messaging that doesn’t match from one department to the next.
A shared baseline gives the whole organization a common language for three conversations:
- Capacity. How can AI help us do more without adding headcount?
- Ethics. What are our shared guardrails?
- Impact. Where will AI actually help our clients and donors the most?
How to build your 2026 AI plan
- Take your baseline first. Spend half an hour rating where you are in fundraising, programs and admin. Be honest. A low score now is useful, because it shows you where to start.
- List the shovelling work. Ask each team for the manual, repetitive tasks that eat their week, like data entry, repetitive drafting and pulling the same report every month. This is the work that burns people out and keeps them from the thinking work they were hired to do.
- Pick a few quick wins for Q1. Choose things you can do in the first month or two that save real time. Early wins build the confidence you’ll need for the bigger work.
- Pick one or two long-term plays. These are the strategic projects for fundraising or programs that take most of the year to land.
- Close your governance gaps. Write down what data can go into which tools and who reviews AI output before it goes out. Do it before people start experimenting widely.
- Book a mid-year check-in now. Don’t wait until Q3 to find out the plan stalled. Put a date in the calendar to compare against your baseline.
For leaders: get past the blank page
The biggest AI hurdle I see heading into 2026 is the blank page. Most leaders know they should be doing something with AI, but writing a strategy from scratch feels like a mountain. So it gets pushed to next month, then next quarter.
You don’t have to write the whole thing alone. Use your first staff meeting of the new year to work through it with your team:
- Where are we strong and where are we weak in fundraising, programs and admin?
- What shovelling work do we want off our plates by summer?
- What are our shared rules for using AI safely?
- Where would AI actually help our donors and clients the most?
My resolution for the sector in 2026 is to use technology to become more human. I’d love to see us spend less time in spreadsheets and more with the people we serve, and less on manual reporting and more on delivering services. If AI can do that, it’ll take some of the burnout out of this work too.
Thanks for being part of this conversation this year. If you’d like a head start on your plan, my free Nonprofit AI Readiness Roadmap asks nine questions and gives you a custom roadmap for fundraising, programs and admin, with quick wins, longer-term next steps and the governance gaps to close.